Old Mill Dark label
Label · tap for full size

Old Mill Dark

Penn Brewery (Pennsylvania)PITTSBURGH, PA
  • Dark Lager / Dunkel
  • 5% ABV
  • Label approved Apr 8, 2025

Had it? My score

90 seek it out · 80 would buy again · 70 fine, wouldn't seek it · 60 disappointing · 40 flawed or drain pour

More from Penn Brewery (Pennsylvania)

See all

Penn Brewery (Pennsylvania)'s Dark Lager / Dunkel. Label approved 8 April 2025.

Right around the middle of the 325 Dark Lager labels we've read.

From the label

“Deep reddish-mahogany in color with sweet caramel malt, nut and coffee notes, and roasted hints. Old Mill Dark is a surprisingly smooth dark beer with a clean finish. This brew feels right out of an old saloon and yet still pairs well with pizza.”

How to serve it

Serve at
44–50°F (7–10°C)
Glass
Mug or stein: thick, sturdy glass that keeps a lager cold

About 155–180 calories and 15–20 g carbs

About 100 of those calories come from the alcohol.

General guidance for Dark Lager / Dunkel. Calories and carbs are estimates from the ABV and how the style usually finishes; numbers the brewery prints beat ours. More beer tools

Where to find it

We track beers, we don't sell them, so no stock promises. These are the searches we'd run for this one.

Readers' scores

About this beer

This is the 4th of 4 labels we have from Pennsylvania Brewing Company. It is one of 30 dark lager / dunkel labels approved in April 2025. Its label was approved 13 days after it was submitted.

Start a four-pour flight with Old Mill DarkThe Pennsylvania scene422 breweries you can visit in Pennsylvania

Brew it

A starting-point recipe from the style and the ABV on the label: derived, not tasted, and the sheet says which is which.

The bench sheet

Ask Hop Grail:

Everything from Penn Brewery (Pennsylvania) is on their page.

Style: LagerBrewery: Penn Brewery (Pennsylvania)